/ Home Page / About WKJCEListen /
/ Artists & Shows / Newsroom / Chat / Links /
/ Garfield25's home page / Who is this Garfield25 anyway /
/ Amherst Alliance   /
/ TO  FRN /

Load peedy

Trans Woman discriminated
 by the state of NY
 and the physician
 Who seen her in 2001...
She and so many like her need our help!!!
WKJCE Received this letter and 
wants to try to help this lady 
and others like her, but we will all need to work together,
As a community...

Here's the scoop...

------------------------------------------------------------------

To Whom It May Concern; April 1 , 2002

My Name is Kristina R.Phillips and I reside in  Fayetteville , Ny 13066. I feel that I have been discriminated by the state of Ny and the physician who seen me in 2001. I had to see this doctor to give me a psychological evaluation to see if I can stay on Disability. There are no laws that protect me and my family against discrimination , according to the human rights division and alot of attorney's. I am very angry that someone of the upper class would discriminate Transgender people.

On that day that is incident happened I had to be there around 9am and I walked into his office and the doctor who performed the exam called out "Mr. Phillips" clearly I was dressed as a woman and had make-up on my face. I stepped into the exam room and he kept referring to me as Mr. Phillips and continued to call me him/he ect....referring to me as Jason Phillips which I changed my name about 1/2 years prior to his exam. As I left his office I said" Oh , By the way , its Kristina Phillips" and he mumbled "dirty faggot" I walked out of there in tears.

There has been 1 supreme court case , 9 circuit court cases and 11 District Court cases and more cases that I don't know about since 1989 for discrimination.

supreme case Price Waterhouse vs. Hopkins , 490 U.S. 228 (1989) (holding that harassment directed at a person because that person does not conform to traditional sex stereotypes is covered by Title VII)

In the year 2000 there was a Hate Crime Committed in Ithica , Ny. There were laws to protect this person from this ever happing again.

Cases Recognizing Protection for transgender people under the state sex and disability discrimination Provisions.

Rentos vs. OCE-Office Systems , 1996 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 19060 (S.D.N.Y. 1996)( refusing to dismiss transsexual woman's claim that she had been discriminated against on the basis of sex violation of the New York State Human Rights Law and the New York City human rights law)

On November 14 , 1996 the international conference on transgender law and employment policy and (NCLR) The National Center for Lesbian Rights.

On July 4 , 1996 The International Bill of Gender rights had been adopted in Huston ,Texas USA ,

Now , my mother sent me a flyer for the Bureau Of Protection and Advocacy New York State Commission on Quality care. I wanted to pursue this so I called them on march 25, 2002 asking them for assistance in this matter. Mr. David T. Hutt the staff attorney. It indicated that I had no laws to protect me. this is what the letter said: "As I indicated there are no legal grounds for you to bring legal action against the doctor and therefore Legal Services will not be able to assist you. Federal and the New York disability discrimination and civil rights laws do not include discrimination based on trans-gendered issues." also Dennis O'Hara another attorney had written me a letter that indicated that he declined to help me in this matter.

I went to court on March 20, 2002 I went in front of Judge Medicis , My records that the court had wasn't all there. I asked the Judge where they went too, he just looked at me and said "I don't know where they could have gone" and that was the last time I hear of that. Aprox. 1 year prior to this a Mrs. Majowski ( hearing officer ) from the Endicott office called my house harassing me because I was to afraid to go to court and she said that she would make me pay for making her drive all that way for no reason. She used vulgar lang. and told me that she would come to my house to pick me up and that I better be ready. I hung up on her , she called back for the 3 rd time and started yelling and screaming at me. I told her that I would have her job and she replied that no one would believe someone like me. I have used the information listed from Transgender law and policy institute/National Center for Lesbian rights/Phyllis Randolph Frye-attorney at law in Huston TX./Christie Lee homepage.

In conclusion I am asking people to write letters to all the government agencies and other groups to fight this matter. I am also going to pursue this case to my fellow friends , family and to those people that their right have been violated. I'm making the public aware of this happening.

Sincerely Yours,
Kristina R Phillips
Fayetteville , Ny 13066

Note : WKJCE Radio edited out the whole address and phone numbers due to the fact there are bad people out there whom love to stalk on us Trans people ...
If you need anymore info feel free to contact Kristina at her e -mail addy

 

The People that will be getting this letter as is listed:

Government Representatives:

Governor Of New York
George E. Pataki
Executive Chamber
State Capitol Albany , NY 12224

Lieutenant Governor
Mary O. Donohue
Executive Chamber State Capitol Albany , NY 12224

Attorney General Of New York
Eliot Spitzer
Department of Law State Capitol Albany , NY 12224

Joan Christensen Member of Assembly - 119TH District
 4317 E. Genesee Street Rm.103 Syracuse , Ny 13214

William Magnarelli Member of Assembly - 120th District
 333 E. Washington St. Rm.840 Sryacuse , NY 13202

Harold Brown Jr. Member of Assembly - 121st District
 5109 W.Genesee St. RM.102 Camillus , NY 13031

County Of Onondaga Representatives:

Nicholas Pirro , County Executive
421 Montgomery St. 14th Floor Sryacuse , NY 13202

Donald Colon , Comptroller
 421 Montgomery St. 14th Floor Syracuse , NY 13202

M.Ann Ciarpelli , County Clerk
 
401 Montgomery St. Rm.200 Syrcause , NY 13202

Willian J. Fitzpatrick , District Attorney
 421 Montgomery St. 12th Floor Syracuse , NY 13202

Kevin Walsh , Sheriff
407 South State St Syrcause , NY 13202

Sandra Baker , 1st District County Legislator
 
20 Sunset Terrace Baldwinsville , NY 13027

Bernard Kraft , 2nd District County Legislator
 49 Bayberry Circle Liverpool , NY 13090

Willian Meyer Jr , 3rd/4th Dictrict County legislator
 8046 Crockett Dv. Cicero , NY 13039

Kathleen Rapp , 5th District County Legislator
 
417 Jewell Dv. Liverpool , NY 13088

James Murphy , 6th District County Legislator
 
15 Onondagd St Skaneateles , NY 13152

Jams DiBlasi , 7th District County Legislator
 
412 Brattle Rd. Sryacuse , NY 13203

James Corbett , 8th District County Legislator
 
122 Lake county Dr. Sryacuse , NY 13209

Mark Stanczyk , 9th District County legislator
 
228 Brattle Rd. Sryacuse , Ny 13203

Terry Pickard , 10th District County legislator
77844 Cahill Rd.
Manlius , Ny 13104

MarthaMulroy , 11th District County Legislator
4968 Cornish heights Pkwy. Syracuse , Ny 13215

Dake Sweetland , 12th District County Legislator
8305 Rt.80 Fabius , NY 13063

Robert Warner Jr. , 13th District County Legislator
1478 Gunbarrel Rd.
Baldwinsville , NY 13027

T. Brenden Whelan , 14th District County legislator
304 Rita Dr. N.Syracuse , NY 13212

Willian Kinne , 15th District County Legislator
321 E. Seneca Turnpike Syracuse , NY 13205

Sam Laguzza , 16th District County Legislator
145 Lilac St Syracuse , NY 13208

Edward Ryan , 17th District County Legislator
324 Coleridge Ave.
Syracuse , NY 13204

Althea Chaplin , 18th District County Legislator
202 South Ave.
Syrcause , NY 13204

Matt Driscoll , Mayor Of Syracuse
108 Winkworth Pkwy.Syracuse , NY 13261

Hillary Clinton , U.S. Senator
100 S. Clinton St. Rm.111 Syracuse , Ny 13261

James Walsh , Representative in Congress -25th District
James M. Hanely Federal Bldg. Rm 1269 Syrcause , Ny 13260

John De Francisco , NYS Senator - 49th District
 
333 E. Washington St. Rm 804 Syracuse , Ny 13202

Nancy Larraine Hoffmann , NYS Senator - 48th District
 333 E. Washington St. Rm 813 Sryacuse , Ny 13202

Willian Sanford , Member of Assembly - 118th District Long Branch Road Liverpool , Ny 13090

The National Center for Lesbian Rights
870 Market St.Ste. 570 San Francisco , CA 94102

Pride Community Center
745 N. Salina St. Sryacuse , Ny 13215

Stonewall Committee
246 E.Water St. Sryacuse , NY 13212

 

 

Ok Want to help but don't know what to write ..
Use these Template letters or even change it to what you need to for your state as well..

Some Ideas

Suggested phrasings

I encourage you...

I hope you will...

Please support...

Please vote for...

Some Pointers .....

If the Senator / U.S. Representative aka "Member of Congress"
aka "Congressman" or "Congresswoman"
 you’re writing is ALREADY On Our Side, please begin by THANKING him or her for past support.
Do this BEFORE you ask for MORE help!!
If you REALLY want to come across as "savvy",
enclose your Original AND one copy --
and add "Cc: Your Communications LA" to the bottom of the letter text
The "Communications LA" is the Legislative Assistant, on the Senator’s or Representative's staff, who specializes in Communications issues.

Template Letters
-------------------------------------------------------

Directions:
For Netscape go to the form where the code is below, right click on the mouse,
use the select all ,it (will highlight the whole letter ),than right click again and use copy and it will copy it.
open WordPad and right click and chose paste
(here you can edit and save the letter )

For IE -Internet explorer: go to the form where the letter is below, right click on the mouse,
use the select all ,it (will highlight the whole letter ),than right click again and use copy and it will copy it.
open WordPad and right click and chose paste
(here you can edit and save the letter )

You can also use Windows shortcuts for copy and paste...

Here's how ..
1. Select the letter either by right click on the form and using the select all function
 or manually highlight the whole letter ...

2. After the whole letter is highlighted press and hold the CTRL button and press the "C" button
 this copy's the highlighted text to your clipboard..

3 Open WordPad or your favorite Word processor program and click you cursor on the Word processor program text area press and hold the CTRL button and press the "V" button This pastes the text into the program where it can be edited saved and printed as well as e-mailed :)

-------------------------------------------------------

Letter One ..
Suggestion for personal experience letter
This letter is setup for writing a house Representative,

Example: If writing a Senator
change the letter heading to 

Senator (INSERT HIS OR HER NAME)
U.S. Senate
Washington, DC 20510

Dear Senator (INSERT HIS OR HER LAST NAME):
-------------------------------------------------------

Letter Two ..
This letter is setup for Erie County Council
On the Recent Human Relations Commission Ordinance
and includes "sexual orientation”
(whether Gay, Straight, Bi, Or Trans)
That is Now Law here in Erie PA :)
See This Page for more details

With a few modifications to this letter ..
You probably could use it for your area as well ..
You may even want to make a reference to Erie's Human Relations Commission Ordinance
What could it hurt ?? :)

-------------------------------------------------------

Letter three

FEEL FREE TO USE THESE "SAMPLE LETTERS" AS A
"STARTING POINT"
FOR DRAFTING YOUR OWN LETTERS
TO LEGISLATORS ON THE
HOUSE AND SENATE COMMERCE COMMITTEES.
WITH A FEW MINOR CHANGES,
THESE "SAMPLES" CAN ALSO BE USED AS A
"STARTING POINT" FOR LETTERS
TO OTHER CONGRESSIONAL LEADERS,
TO CITY COUNCILS, TO STATE LEGISLATURES,
TO THE MEDIA
AND SO ON.

-------------------------------------------------------

Don't know who is you congressman or woman is ???
Well never fear Garfield25 is here !!!
Just use the search below :)

QuickLinks:
 • President & V.P.
 • U.S. Congress
 • State Officials
 • Local Officials

(Note: search results and links will open in a new window)

This info can also be found at http://www.congress.org/
Where you can also e-mail the
  President & V.P., U.S. Congress, 
State Officials and  Local Officials

atvrule.gif (180 bytes)

Garfield25 AKA John / Joanne Lynn
 was recently discriminated against by a
 Dr Bradley Phell's 
P.O. Box 802 
Salina Road
Seneca Pa 16346
814-676-5444
FAX  814  676 -0342

Here's the scoop...

------------------------------------------------------------------

Dr Phell's was both mine and my Ex's (whom is also a transgender person) Doctor.
My Ex used to supply me with hormones knowingly and unknowingly.
I was steady on the hormones since about Sept/Oct 2001...
Well when my Ex left me I was running out of hormones so I had to order them from the net.
I went on vacation to Cleveland during the Christmas season - New Year 2002.
A friend told me I should tell my Dr about the hormones, since he also used to prescribe my Ex's hormones so I called and they set me up a appointment..
Well at my appointment,
He asked what I was taken..
I told him as well as showed him my med list..
Estradiol 2mg 2 tabs a day = 4mg daily
Spriolactone 100 mg 2 tabs daily = 200mg daily
as well as a few of my other meds,
He asked how did I come up with these doses,
I pulled out my Ex's med list ...
He said that's one thing I have noticed about you you seem to be organized and on top of things ..
He wrote the info in my file,
He than asked why didn't I bring to this to his attention earlier,
I told him the reason was I didn't know how to approach this area since
 I don't want anyone to get into trouble..
He asked if I been having any side affects..
like headaches and etc that may come from taking estrogen...
I said the only side affects I seem to have is running out of large shirt to hide these..
I pointed to my shirt ..
He than made a comment about my breasts and how they where growing,
He asked if they were sore, I said they seem to be tender at times..
He asked if I been checking myself regularly for lumps and etc,
I said well No what am I looking for since Being legally blind doesn't help matters any
Even though I have some vision left It's sometimes get hard for me to see things clearly.
So I asked if if he could look and see yeah I trusted him ..
He did and said nope your ok 
He than asked about my liver and felt the area where my liver was..
He said well its not enlarged ..
I asked ok, he explained why and how estrogen may affect the liver..
He wrote in my charts and asked me when was the last time he took blood tests
I told him my last tests where for HIV and other STD's which was done before I went on vacation
Which they all came out as Negative ...
He than said ok I need to do some blood tests to see where your levels are ..
Well in his office they have a lab, the lady took about 5/6 tubes of blood..
Than I asked about refilling my hormones,
 he said I want to wait till your blood work comes back 
and get more info on HRT -Hormone replacement Therapy...
He told me "If you can get any info on it than we can go from there,
In the meantime I'll try to contact a few other Doctors who specialize in this field.."
I asked how long does it take to get blood tests results back, he said a couple days..
"Call me in a few days about it by that time I should have gotten the info I need about this and ..."
I asked him without the hormones
 what will happen to my breasts that I worked hard to grow???
He said they would be reabsorbed by the body"
I'll See you in about 2 weeks"....
I left his office very depressed, it felt like that was nothing but a waste..

I waited a couple days than called his office ,
 got the answering service so left a message for him to call me back...
I waited all day for him to call .. no call
So the next day called it was on a Friday, I believe..
 and left was told by the receptionist that he will get back to me..
Again waited all day and still no call back ...
His office is closed during the weekends ...
So Monday I called, and yes I was very upset..
The receptionist / nurse answered the phone...
I said look I been trying to get a hold of Dr Phell for a couple F" word days now...
He hasn't returned my calls ... What's the F*ing deal...
She said Let me get him for you ...
She put me on hold ...

He came back on the line and asked where do I want my medical records sent..
I said what ?? He repeated ..
I said the last time I talked to you was you told me that you were going to get some info on HRT..
as well as to call you about my blood work ...
He said I was working on the HRT stuff still trying to get a hold of a Doctor who specialize in this field..
No one has returned my call .. 
But it seems you don't want my help, so where do you want your records sent ...
I will not allow you to use vulgar lang towards anyone of my staff...
I had to think what he was referring too...
I said oh, Well I am sorry about that, 
Just seems I am getting the run around after all currently
 you do have someone in your office on hormones .....
He asked who...
I told him My Ex ....
You know the one that
 I was with when she came in for her appointments
 and wanted me to come into the room with her and when she was in the hospital, 
who was there ??
He said you You but I am not allowed to talk about your Ex to you ...
I said I'm not asking about my ex, 
just to look into her file and you will see after all don't you fill her scripts ??
He said I am not allowed to talk to you about your Ex
 and nether are you supposed to be discussing her...
I said She was a part of my life for almost a year
 so Its hard to tell you
 when asked about things 
without referring to me EX after all she was a part of my life ...
And on Set 22nd 2001 She did give me power of attorney over her medical
but I am not asking you to discuss her,
 but I know you are prescribing her hormones 
and she hasn't been through the therapy for them ...
He said well again  I am not allowed to talk to you about your Ex
Do you want to reschedule the appointment or who do I send your records too..
I said lets reschedule the appointment ...
So He put the receptionist back on the line and the appointment was rescheduled...
It was schedule for a different date than what I was given before,
 so I decided to keep the 1st appointment but wrote both dates on my calendar...

In the meantime
I decided to find all I can about Hormones and where I can get some if 
I cant get them prescribed since my supply was demising ...
I came across Anne A. Lawrence's Transgender Resources Site
She had everything I was looking for on one site ...
Everything from hormones and their suggested dosages..
To Buying Hormones on the Internet..
Including the HBIGDA Standards of Care...
Best of all this research was coming from a person with a M.D., Ph.D
A Doctor... humm what better to get my research for Doctor Phell's
through another Doctor...
What a gold mine so I thought,
I saved the pages pertaining to hormones and the dosages
 as well as the studies anything that may be a question with Phell's.
I than converted the web pages into a format that could be sent by my fax program,
and faxed him the whole package ...
Got a call from his office later that day,
Doctor Phell's says the info you sent is very interesting
 but please save any info for your appointment and bring it in with you..
To Late everything had been already faxed ..
But I thought humm don't want any excuses, 
so the next time I visited my parents
 I used their printer 
since mine is broke and printed everything up
 and put it in a file folder labeled Doctor Phell
Ok so I was set now to order some more hormones, so I did..
I printed off the receipts and etc and stuck those in the file as well...
I contacted Anne A. Lawrence and told her what was going on,
very nice lady, 
she was more than willing to talk to my Doctor free of charge for 5 minutes,
And If he needed more time I could set up a consultation for more time
which I would have been happy to pay for...
I told her let me talk to my Doctor and see what he would like to do,
and thank you so much...

Finally the day of my appointment...
the original date ...
With File In hand I walked into his office..
after about a hr wait..
I was called ..
Well needless to say he didn't even want to look at the info in the file ..
I told him about Anne A. Lawrence and how she would be happy to talk to you..
for 5 minutes free of charge and if you want more time, I would be willing to pay for it,
He said don't you mean if I want to pay for it ..
I said If you wanted too but I would pay for it after all it is worth it to me..
He than said He had been doing some research too,
 The Doctors he called says there is no opening they were all dealing with other clients..
He mentioned someone in Cleveland Ohio that may be able to see me..
I told him that the only reason I was in Cleveland, 
 because a friend picked me up for the holidays,
I don't plan on moving there..
Again I tried to bring up Anne A. Lawrence...
He said why don't you go see her since it seems you like her...
I had to laugh .. are you going to provide the transportation to Seattle??
He said NO ,
I said that's my problem, if you read my records
 it tells you about me being legally blind so no I cant drive...
He looked at my record.. Oh..
He said well I don't feel comfortable with giving you hormones
 even though you have talked a local therapist into helping you with the counseling.
However there is a Doctor in Monroeville PA
I asked where's that ??
He said its about 2 hrs from here..
I opened the file and took out the resources page ..
He looked at it and said that's it..
I said 2 hrs Pittsburgh is that far as well..
He looked at the list again..
and than said you may want to contact the Persad Center 
maybe they can help, If you need a referral have them call me..
How are you on your meds, I said other than the hormones I'm fine,
My therapist just refilled my welburtren,
He asked what that was for...
Well if you look in the record you will see that I have ADHD/ADD..
I made a note...OK..
He said however if your sick, broken bones or etc come see me,
I said or if I get HIV/Aids right, 
he shock his head in a up and down motion which confirmed it..
and walked out of the room ..
I went up to the receptionist to see if there was anything else I needed to sign
Nope than was asked when he wanted to see me again..
I told her I don't know when I'm sick maybe ...
She went back to ask him,
She came back and said he says after you talk to the Persad center,
He will want to schedule a appointment ...

I called the Persad Center and seen a intake person
 whom even asked if it was ok to contact my Doctor..
She said we like to work with your family Doctor with the hormones,
I said well good luck that's why I am here ...
He doesn't want anything to do with it ..

Well that's were I'm today..
My hormones finally came in from that web company,
Makes note to use a credit card next time and not a international money order..

I feel I was discriminated against because I don't have HIV/AIDS..
After all Doctor Phell's has set up a HIV/AIDS office in his building...

I have been discriminated against on other occasions as well
 so this isn't the first time and probably wont be the last -sigh

atvrule.gif (180 bytes)

Resources
New York Association for Gender Rights Advocacy

atvrule.gif (180 bytes)

Thanks To Erie Gay News

Back

 

/ Home Page / About WKJCEListen /
/ Artists & Shows / Newsroom / Chat / Links /
/ Garfield25's home page / Who is this Garfield25 anyway /
/ Amherst Alliance   /
/ TO  FRN /